Implicit Bias and Faithful Discernment in Delegation Voting

What Is Implicit Bias?

To recognize implicit bias, we must understand it through an equity and diversity lens:

Implicit: Unconscious thinking that is real and influential. It shapes our thoughts, speech, and actions and may conflict with our stated beliefs, values, or commitments.

Bias: Unconscious thinking that evaluates one person or group relative to another.

Implicit bias is the unconscious thinking that influences how we evaluate people or groups, even when those evaluations do not align with our Christian values, commitments, or intentions. These automatic and unintentional biases can affect our judgments, decisions, and behaviors. The impact is felt by others whether the bias was intentional or not.

Why It Matters in Delegation Voting

Imago Dei reminds us that every person is created in the image of God and bears sacred worth. We are called to discern God’s will together and to love our neighbors as ourselves. During delegation elections and voting processes, implicit bias can influence:

  • Who we perceive as qualified or electable

  • How we assess leadership potential

  • Whose voices we trust or value

  • How decisions about representation and inclusion are shaped

  • Our willingness to support candidates whose backgrounds, experiences, or perspectives differ from our own

Faithful discernment requires us to slow down, reflect, and examine the assumptions we bring into the voting process.

A Biblical Perspective

Jesus often used parables to help people see realities they could not readily recognize. By exposing what was hidden in people’s hearts, he invited reflection and transformation. In Luke 10:25–37, the Parable of the Good Samaritan, Jesus confronts implicit bias by making a Samaritan, a member of a despised group, the center of the story. He teaches that compassion, not social status, identity, or group affiliation, determines what it means to be a neighbor, challenging listeners to see beyond prejudice and recognize the dignity and worth of all people.

Similarly, addressing implicit bias requires us to make the unconscious conscious. We cannot transform what we refuse to acknowledge. God often reveals our blind spots so that we may grow in grace, justice, and faithful discipleship.

Before You Vote, Consider:

Challenge

  • What assumptions am I making about this candidate?

  • Are my impressions based on demonstrated gifts and calling, or on familiarity and comfort with my perception and understanding of delegate leadership?

  • Am I unconsciously favoring candidates who look, think, worship, or lead in ways that feel familiar to me?

Ask

  • Am I evaluating all candidates by the same standards?

  • Have I prayerfully considered how God calls diverse leaders into ministry and service?

  • How does recognizing every candidate as bearing the image of God shape my discernment?

Respond

  • Listen openly to candidates’ experiences, qualifications, and sense of calling.

  • Be mindful of your own stereotypes, assumptions, and unexamined preferences.

  • Seek to honor the dignity, gifts, and leadership potential of every candidate.

  • Seek to create and support a delegation that reflects the broad diversity, gifts, and ministries of the Church.

Questions for Delegates

  1. How can we recognize our implicit biases in the voting process?

  2. How might implicit biases affect the election of delegates and church leaders?

  3. What spiritual practices can help us challenge implicit biases and strengthen faithful discernment?

  4. How can we ensure all candidates are considered fairly and equitably?

Prayerful Invitation

“Search me, O God, and know my heart; test me and know my anxious thoughts” (Psalm 139:23).

May our voting reflect not only our preferences but our commitment to justice, inclusion, humility, and the guidance of the Holy Spirit.